My Family, My Life: The Marstellers (Part 3)

Philip Marsteller, painting by Jacob Frymire (July 1800)

Philip Marsteller, painting by Jacob Frymire (July 1800)

I’m sure that all families have at least one notable person whom everyone talks about, whether they are famous outside of the family or memorable for another reason. Amongst my mother’s side of our family, my “cousin seven times removed” — Philip Marsteller — is the major notable, having been a personal friend of George Washington and the only non-Mason pallbearer at President Washington’s funeral.

Born Philippus Balthasar Marsteller on January 4, 1742 in Philadelphia County (now Montgomery County), Pennsylvania, Philip received a good German and English education and attended the Augustus Evangelical Lutheran Church in Trappe, PA. His father, Frederick Ludwig Marsteller, died when he was 12 and his mother, Anna Barbara Stark, finished raising him on the family homestead. Both parents immigrated to America from Pfungstadt, Hesse, Germany in 1729, joining Frederick’s brother, Johann Georg Marsteller.

When he reached the age of 21, Philip received his portion of his father’s estate which he used to purchase; a tract of land in what is now Mill Creek Township in Lebanon County, Pennsylvania where he remained several years.

On April 22, 1766, Philip married Magdalena Reiss in Trappe, Philadelphia County, who was born on December 22, 1745, in Berks County, Pennsylvania. She died in Alexandria, Virginia, in 1809, aged 63. They had two children: Barbara, born after 1767 in Mill Creek Township, Lebanon County, and died after 1796 in Alexandria; and Philip Gotthelp, born on February 11, 1770, in Mill Creek Township.

At the outset of the American Revolution, he became one of the earliest “associators” and he was very active in raising troops for George Washington’s army in 1775-1776. A Battalion of Associators was formed within Lebanon County in the autumn of 1775. It was commanded by Col. Philip Lorentz Greenwaltz. Philip Marsteller was the Lieutenant Colonel (second in command) of this battalion. In 1776, Philip Marsteller was a member of the Associators Second Battalion, Lancaster County, commanded by Colonel Curtis Grubb.

Philip was a member of the Pennsylvania Constitutional Convention of 1776 (which adopted the first state Constitution), and during that and the following year he was chosen to the Assembly. In 1777, he was appointed Lieutenant Colonel of the 1st Battalion, Lancaster County Associators. He was appointed Paymaster of the militia on August 20, 1777, and, on July 13, was appointed agent to superintend the purchase of flour for the French fleet. He was appointed Assistant Forage-Master on April 5, 1780, for which he received a personal letter of commendation from George Washington thanking him for faithful and prompt performance of his duties. This letter was addressed to Major Philip Marsteller and is in the Library of Congress. He was later named Assistant Deputy Quartermaster General.

Philip settled in the Alexandria, VA area after the war (approximately 1783). With his son, Philip Gotthelp, he engaged in the commission business. He was the auctioneer of Alexandria, and accumulated much valuable furniture, silverware, china, fowling pieces, saddles, pistols, a rare print of Washington, and similar items.

Colonel Marsteller was Mayor of Alexandria, Virginia, from 1790-1792. He was also a member of the Sun Fire Company. In 1793, he advertised as “to let” the property known in 1790 as 130 Prince Street in Alexandria. He lived in a house that was reportedly still standing in 1928 at the southeast corner of Washington and Wolfe streets. The Alexandria Academy stood next to this house built by Col. Marsteller shortly after his arrival in Alexandria. In 1882, the Board of Trustees of the Academy bought the adjoining Marsteller property and used it for the primary grades up to, at least, 1928.

Philip Marsteller long enjoyed the friendship of George Washington. Washington’s last birthday was celebrated at a gathering at Wise’s tavern (northeast corner of Fairfax and Cameron Streets) on February 22, 1799. Both George and Martha attended the observance. Col. Marsteller participated in the arrangements, while ladies listed as attending this “Birth Night Ball” included Mrs. Marsteller and a “Miss” Marsteller, one of Philip’s daughters.

Philip served as a pallbearer at George Washington’s funeral at Mount Vernon on the afternoon of December 19, 1799. Two Masonic lodges of Alexandria and Washington D.C. officiated at the funeral. Mrs. Washington specifically requested Col. Marsteller, who was not a Mason. The honorary pallbearer’s included six Colonels, who had served under General Washington during the Revolutionary War. The other pallbearers in the funeral cortege were Col. Charles Little, Col. Charles Simms, Col. William Payne, Col. George Gilpin, and Col. Dennis Ramsey. Marsteller was joined at Washington’s funeral by his son, Philip Marsteller, Jr., and his grandson, Samuel A. Marsteller.

Philip also served as a Lieutenant in a Military Company of Elders in Alexandria called the “Silver Grey’s” and composed of older veterans of the Revolution. This organization appeared in full uniform with arms for the first Washington’s Birthday Parade through the streets of Old Alexandria on February 22, 1800.

Sameul Arell Marsteller - grandson of Philip, painted by Jacob Frymire (August 1800)

Sameul Arell Marsteller – grandson of Philip, painted by Jacob Frymire (August 1800)

In July and August 1800, noted early American folk artist Jacob Frymire painted portraits of Philip, his wife Magdalena, and grandson Samuel Arell. There were included in a painting exhibition in Washington D.C., in 1975-1976, as was a painting of Philip’s granddaughter, Charlotte. These are the oldest known images of members of the Marsteller family from Pfungstadt. The painting of Charlotte is now in the Corcoran Gallery of Art in Washington D.C. A descendant of Philip Marsteller privately owns the other three paintings. These images were all copied from a book called Jacob Frymire, American Limner by Linda Crocker Simmons.

Charlotte Marsteller - granddaughter of Philip, painted in early 1800's

Charlotte Marsteller – granddaughter of Philip, painted by Jacon Frymire in early 1800’s

Col. Marsteller attended Christ Church, where he occupied pew number 38 (old numbering). He died at his home in Alexandria in December 1803, and was buried in Christ Church yard under a large sycamore tree near the west line of the fence. Col. Marsteller, one of two of Washington’s pallbearers buried there, had a handsome table stone monument. The monument was carried off during the Civil War and disappeared.

Shortly before his own death, Marsteller acquired a pair of matched flintlock pistols had once belonged to George Washington. The pistols were bought from the estate of Bartholomew Dandridge, former Private Secretary to George Washington. They were 14 inches long, with brass barrel, full-length walnut stock and seven solid silver inlays, including a grotesque mask on the butt; a rolled edge and engraved trigger guard; a panoply of arms on the cut-out side plates which show cannon, flags, drums, pole arms, a lion, and a unicorn.

Richard Wilson and John Hawkins, gun makers in London, had made the pistols in 1748. Thomas Turner, whose grandfather had known Washington as a youth, gave the pistols to Washington in 1778. The pistols remained in Washington’s possession during much of the Revolutionary War. Before he died, Washington gave the pistols to Bartholomew Dandridge, his wife’s nephew and his secretary for six years. Dandridge survived only a few years after Washington’s death, and, after his death, Philip purchased the pistols.

In 1902, the pistols were sold to an antique arms dealer — Francis Bannerman — at an estate auction near Warrenton, VA. In 1914, the pistols were sold to collector Edward Litchfield. In 1951, the Litchfield collection was sold to Clendennin Ryan. In 1953, he presented them to the U.S. Military Academy at West Point where they currently reside in the West Point Museum. In 1978, the U.S. Historical Society with headquarters in Richmond Virginia, commissioned a limited edition of 975 pairs of commemorative replicas of the pistols, which were offered to the public for $2,600.

Currently, there are five letters between Philip Marsteller and George Washington in the National Archives available for reading online:

13 thoughts on “My Family, My Life: The Marstellers (Part 3)

  1. Mark, you mentioned in “Part 2” the Marstellers began immigrating to America in the year 1727, Frederick being one of the first. The very first to arrive in America was Joh. Georg Marsteller born 9/4/1619 in Phungstadt and died 10/19/1751 in Upper Saucon Township, Bucks County, PA, now Lehigh County. He arrived in Philadelphia aboard the ship “Adventure” in 1727 and Fredrick, his younger brother, arrived in 1729 aboard the ship “Mortonhouse” in 1729. This information is based on extensive research by George Marsteller, Ohio, who I presume has passed-away. However, when I searched the 1727 passenger list for the “Adventure” I find no record for Joh. Georg Marsteller. I am hoping you can provide some further information.
    Thank you for considering my request.
    Harold I. Masteller
    Born 10/18/1942 Bethlehem, PA
    Now living 105 Meadows Drive, Springboro, OH 45066
    (937) 885-7481

    p.s. Your 3-Part History is Great!

    • Thank you for the information. Unfortunately, I have no further information on Joh. Georg Marsteller, nor have I yet been able to find anything else. One of the disadvantages I have living in Thailand is that a lot of the primary sources are unavailable to me. I have a long list of “to do’s” should I ever make it back to the States….

  2. Appears we are related. I am currently researching family history. I am a descendant of George, brother of Frederic L and Peter, Henry was one of his sons, then I go to Samuel, Samuel Aaron then Hannah who married George Sircoulomb who was the father of my Grandmother, Edmere Marsteller Sircoulomb Dilley. You did a great job on this blog. Has inspired me in making a book for my Grandchildren with images of the places our families lived. Thank you for sharing.

    • Thank you for your kind comments. I really wish I had more time (and resources!) to devote to researching family history. It’s still just a part-time hobby with me and I often find it difficult trying to do research from Thailand. The Internet only helps to a certain point and then I think it’s best to try and visit places such as genealogical libraries to find the real details. Good luck in your search and I hope to add your details to the tree.

  3. Pingback: Washington’s Birthday – A Stamp A Day

  4. Pingback: The Battle of Newtown in General Sullivan’s Scorched Earth Campaign – A Stamp A Day

  5. Pingback: Great Smoky Mountains, Tennessee – Postcards to Phuket

  6. I recently took a deep dive into genealogy and the Marstellers are part of my tree. Johan Georg was my 3rd cousin 9 times removed. I have roots in other places in Germany (Schwabsburg, Nierstein), and recently discovered the Marstellers. My third great-grandmother was a Marsteller. I frequently travel to Europe for pleasure, and my next trip was going to be to Germany to visit where my ancestors are from, but I guess it will have to wait. Damn, coronavirus.

    • Hello Margaret
      My Grandfather was Joy Dale Marsteller and is a direct decendent of Col. Phillip Masteller. I have a very old catalog that has a picture and description of a sword that was give to Phillip by G. Washington.

  7. Greetings from a fellow Marsteller. I am the son of Nancy-Clay Marsteller, grandson of Brutus Junius Clay Marsteller of Kentucky.

    I came across your page when seeking to teach my 9 and 11 year olds a bit of family history. I was aware of the Philip Marsteller story, but am surprised that so little has been written about him.

  8. Pingback: A Cover A Day #9: 15 February 2021 – My Connection to George Washington – Philatelic Pursuits

  9. Pingback: A Postcard A Day #31: 18 June 2021 – Mount Vernon – Postcards to Phuket

  10. Just a quick note from a direct Philip Marsteller relative. I am related from my great grandmother, Louisa Marstella Patten, Marstella being one of the name differences. My cousin and I attended the 200th anniversary of Washington’s funeral on 1998 at Mount Vernon. Col. Marsteller was portrayed by a descendant. Thanks for all info.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.